Life after Death: Difference between revisions
Pablo Sender (talk | contribs) |
Pablo Sender (talk | contribs) |
||
(42 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
[[File:Ascent of the Blessed.jpg|right|150px|thumb|Ascent of the Blessed by Bosch]] | |||
According to the [[Theosophy|Theosophical]] teachings after the [[death]] of the body, [[consciousness]] undergoes a series of transformations. The tendencies, emotions, thoughts, memories, and aspirations that were part of the [[Principle#Individuality_and_personality|personality]] are sorted out. Anything that belonged to the entirely personal and selfish aspect is discarded, while all that was of a generous or unselfish nature is preserved and assimilated by the [[Soul#Human soul|soul]]. In the writings of [[Helena Petrovna Blavatsky|H. P. Blavatsky]] and the [[Masters of Wisdom]] the most frequent description of the different stages after physical death include: a) [[kamaloka]], b) [[gestation period]], c) [[devachan]], and d) [[reincarnation]]. | |||
== General description == | == General description == | ||
[[File:Divina Comedia.jpg|left|250px|thumb|After death landscape according to Dante]] | |||
In the [[Theosophy|Theosophical]] view, [[death]] is not the end of conscious experience but, on the contrary, it is the beginning of a wider consciousness. [[Helena Petrovna Blavatsky|H. P. Blavatsky]] said: | |||
What is known as " | <blockquote>We accept consciousness after death, and say the real consciousness and the real freedom of the [[Ego]] or the [[soul]] begins only after the physical death of man. It is then that it is no longer impeded by terrestrial matter that it is free, that it can perceive everything.<ref>Michael Gomes (transcriber), ''The Secret Doctrine Commentaries'' (The Hague: I.S.I.S. foundation, 2010), 44.</ref></blockquote> | ||
What is known as "death" involves the departure of the [[Prāṇa|vital principle]] and the consequent dissolution of the [[Sthūla-śarīra|physical body]] along with its [[Liṅga-śarīra|astral double]] of etheral matter. After this, comes a period of dissolution of the [[Soul#Animal soul|animal soul]] and the personal aspect of the [[Soul#Animal soul|human soul]] in [[Kāmaloka]]. Finally, the spiritual aspect of the human soul is assimilated by the [[Soul#Spiritual soul|spiritual soul]] in [[Devachan]]. In Mme. Blavatsky's words: | |||
<blockquote>Soul being a generic term, there are in men three aspects of Soul - the terrestrial, or animal; the Human Soul; and the Spiritual Soul; these, strictly speaking, are one Soul in its three aspects. Now of the first aspect nothing remains after death; of the second (nous or [[Manas]]) only its divine essence if left unsoiled survives, while the third in addition to being immortal becomes consciously divine, by the assimilation of the higher Manas.<ref>Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, "The Key to Theosophy" (Pasadena, CA: Theosophical University Press, 1972), 121-122.</ref></blockquote> | <blockquote>Soul being a generic term, there are in men three aspects of Soul - the terrestrial, or animal; the Human Soul; and the Spiritual Soul; these, strictly speaking, are one Soul in its three aspects. Now of the first aspect nothing remains after death; of the second (nous or [[Manas]]) only its divine essence if left unsoiled survives, while the third in addition to being immortal becomes consciously divine, by the assimilation of the higher Manas.<ref>Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, "The Key to Theosophy" (Pasadena, CA: Theosophical University Press, 1972), 121-122.</ref></blockquote> | ||
The spiritual soul or [[Buddhi]], by itself | The [[Soul#Spiritual soul|spiritual soul]] or [[Buddhi]] is of a universal nature and, by itself, it lacks the element of self-awareness. After death it can become conscious of its own divine nature by assimilating the spiritual elements of the mental consciousness, if the person ever exercised this aspect of his mind. | ||
The different stages have been described by [[Koot Hoomi|Master K.H.]] in [[Mahatma Letter No. 68#Page 15|one of his letters]] as follows: | |||
<blockquote>The period between death and rebirth . . . may last from a few years to a [[kalpa]]. It is divided into three sub-periods (1) when the [[Ego]] delivered of its mortal coil enters into [[Kāmaloka|Kama-Loka]] (the abode of [[Elementary|Elementaries]]); (2) when it enters into its "Gestation State"; (3) when it is reborn in the [[Devachan#Rupa and Arupa Lokas|Rupa-Loka]] of Deva-Chan. Sub-period (1) may last from a few minutes to a number of years — the phrase "a few years" becoming puzzling and utterly worthless without a more complete explanation; Sub-period (2) is "very long"; as you say, longer sometimes than you may even imagine, yet proportionate to the Ego's spiritual stamina; Sub-period (3) lasts in proportion to the good [[Karma|KARMA]], after which the [[monad]] is again [[reincarnation|reincarnated]].<ref>Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., ''The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence'' No. 68 (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 194.</ref></blockquote> | |||
== Kama-loka == | |||
[[File:Purgatorio de dante.jpg|right|250px|thumb|Purgatory according to Dante]] | |||
After the disposal of the three lower [[principle]]s of consciousness that happen during physical [[death]], the four principles remaining enter in [[Kāmaloka]], which is an intermediate sphere between the physical and the spiritual. Before consciousness can pass on to [[devachan]], a "purification" of the psychic elements is necessary. As [[Helena Petrovna Blavatsky|H. P. Blavatsky]] wrote: | |||
<blockquote>When the spiritual [[monad]] striving to enter the Devachanic state is being subjected to the process of purification, what happens is this: personal consciousness, which alone constitutes the [[Ego#Lower ego|personal Ego]], has to rid itself of every earthly speck of grossly material taint before it becomes capable of living “in spirit” and as a spirit.<ref>Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, ''Collected Writings'' vol. VI (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1989), 328.</ref></blockquote> | |||
<blockquote>If, on the other hand, it is the Upper Duality which is defeated, then it is the fifth principle that assimilates all that there may be left of personal recollection and perceptions of its personal individuality in the sixth. | <blockquote>Kama-loka may be compared to the dressing-room of an actor, in which he divests himself of the costume of the last part he played before rebecoming himself properly - the immortal [[Ego]] or the Pilgrim cycling in his Round of Incarnations. The Eternal Ego [is] stripped in Kama-loka of its lower terrestrial principles, with their passions and desires. . . . But the process of stripping off the lower, the [[Kāma|fourth]] and [[Manas#Lower manas|part of the fifth]], principles is an unconscious one in all normal human beings. It is only in very exceptional cases that there is a slight return to consciousness in Kama-loka: and this is the case of very materialistic unspiritual personalities, who, devoid of the conditions requisite, cannot enter the state of absolute Rest and Bliss.<ref>Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, ''Collected Writings'' vol. IX (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1974), 164.</ref></blockquote> | ||
During this period there is a tension between the two lower principles, which possess a tendency towards materiality, and the two higher, which are of a spiritual nature. What happens can be metaphorically seen as a "struggle" between the animal and the spiritual aspects of the soul ([[Kāma]] and [[Buddhi]] respectively) to assimilate [[Manas]]. In [[Mahatma Letter No. 68#Page 11|one of his letters]], [[Koot Hoomi|Master K.H.]] explained the process as follows: | |||
<blockquote>When man dies his [[Liṅga-śarīra|second]] and [[Prāṇa|third]] principles die with him; the lower triad disappears, and the fourth, fifth, [[Buddhi|sixth]] and [[Ātman|seventh]] principles form the surviving Quaternary. . . . Thenceforth it is a "death" struggle between the Upper and Lower dualities. If the upper wins, the sixth, having attracted to itself the quintessence of Good from the fifth — its nobler affections, its saintly (though they be earthly) aspirations, and the most Spiritualised portions of its mind — follows its divine elder (the 7th) into the "Gestation" State; and the fifth and fourth remain in association as an empty [[Kāmaloka#Shells|shell]] . . . to roam in the earth's atmosphere, with half the personal memory gone, and the more brutal instincts fully alive for a certain period.<ref>Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., ''The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence'' No. 68 (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 192-193.</ref></blockquote> | |||
After the death struggle the two higher principles, along with the spiritual essence of manas, enter into a [[Life after Death#Period of gestation|period of gestation]]. Meanwhile, the fourth principle (Kāma), with whatever personal and selfish element it could retain from the manasic principle, forms a shell and stays in Kāmaloka to be eventually dissolved. However, it may happen that the upper duad does not succeed in assimilating any spiritual essence from the lower one. In such a case that particular personal life is completely useless to the [[Monad]], and is "erased" from its records. As the Master continued saying: | |||
<blockquote>If, on the other hand, it is the Upper Duality which is defeated, then it is the fifth principle that assimilates all that there may be left of personal recollection and perceptions of its personal individuality in the sixth. . . . The sixth and seventh [principles] — now a purely spiritual, individual MONAD, with nothing left in it of the late personality, having no regular “gestation” period to pass through (since there is no purified personal Ego to be reborn), after a more or less prolonged period of unconscious Rest in the boundless Space — will find itself reborn in another personality on the next planet. When arrives the period of “Full Individual Consciousness” — which precedes that of Absolute Consciousness in the [[Nirvāṇa#Parinirvāṇa|Pari-Nirvana]] — this lost personal life becomes as a torn out page in the great Book of Lives, without even a disconnected word left to mark its absence. The purified monad will neither perceive nor remember it in the series of its past rebirths — which it would had it gone to the “World of Forms” ([[Devachan#Rupa_and_Arupa_Lokas|rupa-loka]]) — and its retrospective glance will not perceive even the slightest sign to indicate that it had been.<ref>Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., ''The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence'' No. 68 (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 193.</ref></blockquote> | |||
In this case, the discarded personal elements do not become a regular "shell" to be dissolved in Kāmaloka. With the additional consciousness gained by retaining all the manasic elements used in that incarnation, it has enough cohesion to be [[Reincarnation|reincarnated]] as a soul-less entity on earth. This state is called [[Avichi]] (see [[Life_after_Death#Avichi|below]]). | |||
== Period of gestation == | == Period of gestation == | ||
[[Alfred Percy Sinnett|A. P. Sinnett]] wrote: | In most cases the upper duad finds some spiritual elements that allows it to be "born" in [[Devachan]]. But before this is possible the soul has to undergo a period of spiritual gestation. [[Alfred Percy Sinnett|A. P. Sinnett]] wrote: | ||
<blockquote>When the division of, or purification of the [[Manas|fifth principle]] has been accomplished in [[Kāmaloka|Kama loca]] by the contending attractions of the [[Kāma|fourth]] and [[Buddhi|sixth]] principles, the real [[Ego]] passes into a period of unconscious gestation . . . a spiritual ante-natal state at the entrance to spiritual life . . . and this period, in different cases, may be of very different duration--from a few moments to immense periods of years.<ref>Alfred Percy Sinnett, ''Esoteric Buddhism'' (San Diego, CA: Wizards Bookshelf, 1987), 96-97.</ref></blockquote> | |||
According to [[Helena Petrovna Blavatsky|H. P. Blavatsky]] the gestation period "lasts from a few days to several years",<ref>Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, ''Collected Writings'' vol. IV (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1991), 120-121.</ref> while [[Koot Hoomi|Mahatma K.H.]] wrote that it can be very long: "longer sometimes than you may even imagine, yet proportionate to the Ego's spiritual stamina".<ref>Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., ''The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence'' No. 68 (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 194.</ref> | |||
It is usually said that the reviving of consciousness begins at the door of Devachan, once the struggle in Kama-Loka is over, but only after the period of gestation:<ref>Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., ''The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence'' No. 104 (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 362.</ref> | |||
<blockquote>That remembrance will return slowly and gradually toward the end of the gestation (to the entity or Ego), still more slowly but far more imperfectly and incompletely to the [[Kāmaloka#Shells|shell]], and fully to the Ego at the moment of its entrance into the Devachan.<ref>Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., ''The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence'' No. 104 (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 362.</ref></blockquote> | |||
However, there are some statements that indicate the possibility of consciousness before Devachan (see [[Devachan#Is there consciousness before Devachan?|below]]). | |||
Regarding the total time elapsed by a normal person in Kāmaloka (that is, during the death struggle and the period of gestation), Mme. Blavatsky wrote: | |||
<blockquote>The normal period during which any part of the consciousness remains in Kâma-Loka, i.e., is connected with the Kâma-Rûpa, is one hundred and fifty years. The Kâma-Rûpa eventually breaks up, and leaving in Kâma-Loka the [[Life-Atom#Tanhic_elementals|Tânhic Elementals]], its remaining portions [[Metempsychosis#Transmigration of atoms|go into animals]].<ref>Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, ''Collected Writings'' vol. XII (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1980), 708.</ref></blockquote> | |||
=== Read more === | |||
[[Gestation period]] | |||
== Devachan == | == Devachan == | ||
[[File:Paradise by Fanti at Melk Abbey.jpg|left|300px|thumb|Pallas Athena on a chariot drawn by lions as a symbol of wisdom, by G. Fanti]] | |||
After the period of gestation, the new "devachanic ego" (that is, the pure elements of the [[Ego#Lower ego|personal ego]] that have been assimilated to the two higher [[principle]]s) begins to awaken in [[Devachan]]: | |||
<blockquote>The Eternal [[Ego]] being stripped in [[Kāmaloka|Kama-loka]] of its lower terrestrial principles, with their passions and desires, it enters into the state of Devachan. And therefore it is said that only the purely spiritual, the non-material emotions, affections and aspirations accompany the Ego into that state of Bliss.<ref>Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, ''Collected Writings'' vol. IX (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1974), 164.</ref></blockquote> | |||
In [[Mahatma Letter No. 68#Page 5|one of his letters]], [[Koot Hoomi|Master K.H.]] wrote: | |||
<blockquote>"Who goes to Deva Chan?" The personal Ego of course, but beatified, purified, holy. Every Ego - the combination of the sixth and seventh principles - which after the period of unconscious gestation is reborn into the Devachan, is of necessity as innocent and pure as a new-born babe. The fact of his being reborn [in Devachan] at all, shows the preponderance of good over [[evil]] in his old personality. And while the [[Karma]] (of evil) steps aside for the time being to follow him in his future earth-[[reincarnation]]s, he brings along with him but the Karma of his good deeds, words, and thoughts, into this Devachan.<ref>Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., ''The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence'' No. 68 (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 190.</ref></blockquote> | |||
In Devachan, the person enjoys the result of the good actions done in the life just finished, as well as receives a compensation for the unmerited suffering experienced: | |||
<blockquote>Devachan is the idealized continuation of the terrestrial life just left behind, a period of retributive adjustment, and a reward for unmerited wrongs and sufferings undergone in that special Life.<ref>Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, ''The Key to Theosophy'' (London: Theosophical Publishing House, [1987]), 132.</ref></blockquote> | |||
== Reincarnation == | |||
When the period of [[Devachan]] is over, the [[Ego#Higher ego|higher ego]] begins the process of [[reincarnation]]. Before it is reborn, however, it sees the life about to be started in its general characteristics, as delineated by its [[Karma]]. [[Helena Petrovna Blavatsky|Mme. Blavatsky]] wrote: | |||
<blockquote>The [[Ātman|seventh]] and the [[Buddhi|sixth]] [principles], that is to say the immortal spirit and its vehicle, the immortal or spiritual soul, enter therein alone (an exceptional case) | <blockquote>As the man at the moment of death has a retrospective insight into the life he has led, so, at the moment he is reborn on to earth, the Ego, awaking from the state of Devachan, has a prospective vision of the life which awaits him, and realizes all the causes that have led to it. He realizes them and sees futurity, because it is between Devachan and re-birth that the Ego regains his full manasic consciousness, and rebecomes for a short time the god he was, before, in compliance with Karmic law, he first descended into matter and incarnated in the first man of flesh.<ref>Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, ''The Key to Theosophy'' (London: Theosophical Publishing House, [1987]), 162-163.</ref></blockquote> | ||
== Avichi == | |||
Most people go to Devachan, with the exception of those very materialistic, selfish, or evil, in whom there is no spiritual [[manas]]ic elements that can be assimilated by [[Buddhi]]. In this case, when no formation of a devachanic ego is possible, the higher principles fall into a state of unconsciousness<ref>Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., ''The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence'' No. 68 (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 193.</ref> and the lower principles are eventually annihilated. [[Helena Petrovna Blavatsky|Mme. Blavatsky]] explained: | |||
<blockquote>The [[Ātman|seventh]] and the [[Buddhi|sixth]] [principles], that is to say the immortal [[spirit]] and its vehicle, the immortal or [[Soul#Spiritual soul|spiritual soul]], enter therein alone (an exceptional case). . . . The | |||
[[Ego#Lower ego|personal EGO]] (the material soul) . . . in the case of the irredeemably wicked and when the spiritual and impersonal soul has nothing to withdraw from its individuality (terrestrial personality) because the latter had nothing to offer but the purely material and sensual - that becomes annihilated.<ref>Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, ''Collected Writings'' vol. V (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1997), 42.</ref></blockquote> | |||
In [[Mahatma Letter No. 68#Page 11|one of his letters]], [[Koot Hoomi|Master K.H.]] explained the fate of the lower duad when it assimilates all the [[manas]]ic elements as follows: | |||
<blockquote>With all this additional stock, it will not remain in [[Kāmaloka|Kama-Loka]] — “the world of Desire” or our Earth’s atmosphere. In a very short time like a straw floating within the attraction of the vortices and pits of the Maelstrom, it is caught up and drawn into the great whirlpool of [[Ego#Lower ego|human Egos]].<ref>Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., ''The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence'' No. 68 (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 193.</ref></blockquote> | |||
Mme. Blavatsky elaborated: | |||
<blockquote>Expelled forever from the consciousness of the Individuality (the [[Ego#Higher ego|reincarnating Ego]]), the physical atoms and psychic vibrations of the now separate personality are immediately [[reincarnation|reincarnated]] on the same earth, only in a lower and still more abject creature, a human being only in form, doomed to [[Karma|Karmic]] torments during the whole of its new life. Moreover, if it persists in its criminal or debauched course, it will suffer a long series of such immediate reincarnations.<ref>Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, ''Collected Writings'' vol. XII (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1980), 632-633.</ref></blockquote> | |||
This state is called [[Avichi]] and could loosely be compared to a concept of [[hell]] for the lost personality (not for the [[Monad]]). | |||
== Is there consciousness before Devachan? == | == Is there consciousness before Devachan? == | ||
In the early [[Theosophy|Theosophical]] literature there are several statements suggesting consciousness only | In the early [[Theosophy|Theosophical]] literature there are several statements suggesting consciousness only begins after the struggle in [[Kama-Loka]] at the door of [[Devachan]]: | ||
<blockquote>Every just disembodied four-fold entity — whether it died a natural or violent death, from suicide or accident, mentally sane or insane, young or old, good, bad, or indifferent — loses at the instant of [[death]] all recollection, it is mentally — annihilated; it sleeps it’s [[Akasha|akasic]] sleep in the [[Kama-loka]]. This state lasts from a few hours, (rarely less) days, weeks, months — sometimes to several years. All this according to the entity, to its mental status at the moment of [[death]], to the character of its [[death]], etc. That remembrance will return slowly and gradually toward the end of the [[gestation]] | <blockquote>Every just disembodied four-fold entity — whether it died a natural or violent death, from suicide or accident, mentally sane or insane, young or old, good, bad, or indifferent — loses at the instant of [[death]] all recollection, it is mentally — annihilated; it sleeps it’s [[Akasha|akasic]] sleep in the [[Kama-loka]]. This state lasts from a few hours, (rarely less) days, weeks, months — sometimes to several years. All this according to the entity, to its mental status at the moment of [[death]], to the character of its [[death]], etc. That remembrance will return slowly and gradually toward the end of the [[Life after Death#Period of gestation|gestation]]. . .<ref>Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., ''The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence'' No. 85-B (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 263.</ref></blockquote> | ||
However, there are some statements that open the possibility of consciousness before [[devachan]]. For example, [[H. P. Blavatsky|Mme. Blavatsky]] wrote: | However, there are some statements that open the possibility of consciousness before [[devachan]]. For example, [[H. P. Blavatsky|Mme. Blavatsky]] wrote: | ||
<blockquote>A “spirit,” or the spiritual Ego, cannot descend to the medium, but it can attract the spirit of the latter to itself, and it can do this only during the two intervals—before and after its “gestation period.” Interval the first is that period between the physical death and the merging of the spiritual Ego into that state which is known in the Arhat esoteric doctrine as “Bar-do.” We have translated this as the “gestation” period, and it lasts from a few days to several years, according to the evidence of the adepts. Interval the second lasts so long as the merits of the old Ego entitle the being to reap the fruit of its reward in its new regenerated Egoship. It occurs after the gestation period is over, and the new spiritual Ego is reborn—like the fabled Phœnix from its ashes—from the old one. The locality, which the former inhabits, is called by the northern Buddhist Occultists “Deva-chan”. . .<ref>Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, ''Collected Writings'' vol. IV (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1991), 120-121.</ref></blockquote> | <blockquote>A “spirit,” or the [[Ego#Spiritual ego|spiritual Ego]], cannot descend to the [[Mediumship|medium]], but it can attract the spirit of the latter to itself, and it can do this only during the two intervals—before and after its “gestation period.” Interval the first is that period between the physical death and the merging of the spiritual Ego into that state which is known in the [[Esoteric Philosophy#Arhat Esoteric Philosophy|Arhat esoteric doctrine]] as “Bar-do.” We have translated this as the “gestation” period, and it lasts from a few days to several years, according to the evidence of the [[adepts]]. Interval the second lasts so long as the merits of the old Ego entitle the being to reap the fruit of its reward in its new regenerated Egoship. It occurs after the gestation period is over, and the new spiritual Ego is reborn—like the fabled Phœnix from its ashes—from the old one. The locality, which the former inhabits, is called by the northern Buddhist Occultists “Deva-chan”. . .<ref>Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, ''Collected Writings'' vol. IV (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1991), 120-121.</ref></blockquote> | ||
As can be seen, she describes here the following sequence: | As can be seen, she describes here the following sequence: | ||
Line 53: | Line 110: | ||
2- First interval. | 2- First interval. | ||
3- [[Gestation]]. | 3- [[Gestation period|Gestation]]. | ||
4- Second interval ([[Devachan]]). | 4- Second interval ([[Devachan]]). | ||
She mentions that the [[Ego#Spiritual ego|Spiritual Ego]] can attract to its own sphere the spirit of the medium in either of the intervals, which suggests there can be consciousness before the [[Gestation|period of gestation]]. | She mentions that the [[Ego#Spiritual ego|Spiritual Ego]] can attract to its own sphere the spirit of the [[Mediumship|medium]] in either of the intervals, which suggests there can be consciousness before the [[Gestation|period of gestation]]. According to her, this can happen "when the intensity of the desire in the dying person to return for some purpose forced the higher consciousness to remain awake".<ref>Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, ''The Key to Theosophy'' (London:Theosophical Publishing House, [1987]), 151.</ref></blockquote> | ||
=== According to Annie Besant === | |||
Dr. [[Annie Besant]] explained that "if a person has led a pure life and has steadfastly striven to rise and to identify himself with the higher rather than the lower part of his nature" the staying in [[Kāmaloka]] is short and normally unconscious. However, in those who during life have being attached to sensual pleasures the situation is different: | |||
<blockquote>Human beings, who have quitted earth and in whom the kāmic elements were strong, may very readily be attracted by the kāmic elements in embodied men, and by their help become conscious again of the presence of the scenes they had left; and human beings still embodied may set up methods of communication with the disembodied, and may, as said, leave their own bodies for awhile, and become conscious in Kāmaloka by the use of faculties through which they have accustomed their consciousness to act.<ref>Annie Besant, ''Death--And After?'' (Adyar, Madras:Theosophical Publishing House, 1977), 31.</ref></blockquote> | |||
== | == See also == | ||
*[[Death]] | |||
*[[Kāmaloka]] | |||
*[[Gestation period]] | |||
*[[Devachan]] | |||
*[[Avichi]] | |||
==Online resources== | ==Online resources== | ||
===Articles and pamphlets=== | ===Articles and pamphlets=== | ||
*[ | * [https://www.theosophy.world/encyclopedia/death-and-after-death-states Death and After-Death States] in Theosophy World | ||
*[ | * [https://www.theosophy.world/encyclopedia/death-second Death, Second] in Theosophy World | ||
*[ | * [https://www.theosophy.world/encyclopedia/earthbound-entities Earthbound Entities] in Theosophy World | ||
*[http://www.blavatsky.net/ | * [https://www.theosophy.world/encyclopedia/eight-sphere Eight Sphere] in Theosophy World. | ||
*[http://www.blavatsky.net/ | *[https://cdn.website-editor.net/e4d6563c50794969b714ab70457d9761/files/uploaded/AdyarPamphlet_No108.pdf# Life, and Life After Death] by Annie Besant | ||
*[https://cdn.website-editor.net/e4d6563c50794969b714ab70457d9761/files/uploaded/AdyarPamphlet_No61.pdf# When a Man Dies, Shall He Live Again?] by Annie Besant | |||
*[http://www.blavatsky.net/index.php/17-hpblavatsky/hpb-articles/270-dialogue-on-mysteries-of-after-life# Dialogue On The Mysteries Of The After Life] by H. P. Blavatsky | |||
*[http://www.blavatsky.net/index.php/life-and-death# Life and Death] by H. P. Blavatsky | |||
*[http://hpb.narod.ru/AfterDeathConsciousnessA.htm# The After-death Consciousness and Processes] by Geoffrey Farthing | *[http://hpb.narod.ru/AfterDeathConsciousnessA.htm# The After-death Consciousness and Processes] by Geoffrey Farthing | ||
*[http://www.teozofija.info/Theosophia/Theosophia_Vol26_No1.htm#AfterDeath# After Death: You are Yourself] by G. de Purucker | *[http://www.teozofija.info/Theosophia/Theosophia_Vol26_No1.htm#AfterDeath# After Death: You are Yourself] by G. de Purucker | ||
*[http://www.theosophical.org/files/resources/articles/PersonalitySurvive.pdf# Does the Personality Survive?] by L. W. Rogers | *[http://www.theosophical.org/files/resources/articles/PersonalitySurvive.pdf# Does the Personality Survive?] by L. W. Rogers | ||
*[http://www.blavatsky.net/topics/near-death- | *[http://www.blavatsky.net/index.php/near-death-experiences/36-topics/reincarnation/near-death-exp/62-what-is-death# The Transpersonal Model of Death as Presented in Madame Blavatsky's Theosophy] by Jean-Louis Siémons | ||
*[http://www.theosophical.org/online-resources/leaflets/1794# Death and Life Beyond] by Theosophical Society in America | *[http://www.theosophical.org/online-resources/leaflets/1794# Death and Life Beyond] by Theosophical Society in America | ||
===Books=== | ===Books=== | ||
*[http://hpb.narod.ru/DeathAndAfterAB.html# Death - and After?] by Annie Besant | *[http://hpb.narod.ru/DeathAndAfterAB.html# Death - and After?] by Annie Besant | ||
*[http://davidpratt.info/survival1.htm# Life beyond Death: evidence for survival] by David Pratt | |||
*[https://cdn.website-editor.net/e4d6563c50794969b714ab70457d9761/files/uploaded/AfterDeathConsciousnessAndProcesses_GFarthing.pdf# After Death Consciousness and Processes] by Geoffrey Farthing | |||
*[https://theosophy.wiki/w/images/c/cf/Books_on_Life_After_Death_-_D._Caldwell.pdf# Book list on "Life After Death"] compiled by Daniel H. Caldwell | |||
===Audio=== | ===Audio=== | ||
*[http://www.theosophical.org/files/resources/Downloads/mp3/codd/Life%20on%20the%20Other%20Side%20of%20Death.mp3 Life on the Other Side of Death] by Clara Codd | *[http://www.theosophical.org/files/resources/Downloads/mp3/codd/Life%20on%20the%20Other%20Side%20of%20Death.mp3 Life on the Other Side of Death] by Clara Codd | ||
*[https://theosophy.world/sites/default/files/audio/Hodson,%20G/317%20Hodson,%20G%20Through%20the%20Gateway%20of%20Death.mp3# Through the Gateway of Death] by Geoffrey Hodson | |||
*[http://www.theosophicalinstitute.org/medialibrary/viewtitle.php?titleid=2C93CB97-60D8-11D6-9AE9-003048223922# Tibetan Contributions to Our Knowledge of Death and Dying (4 parts)] by Glenn Mullin | *[http://www.theosophicalinstitute.org/medialibrary/viewtitle.php?titleid=2C93CB97-60D8-11D6-9AE9-003048223922# Tibetan Contributions to Our Knowledge of Death and Dying (4 parts)] by Glenn Mullin | ||
===Video=== | ===Video=== | ||
*[ | *[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3h6hm0as91s I'm Dead! Now What?] by Dick Brooks | ||
*[ | *[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YyIBbOkaDwU& A Theosophical View of Life after Death] by Pablo Sender | ||
*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8B9fFD4h_4M# What Happens When We Die] by Blavatsky Trust | |||
== Additional resources == | |||
*[http://www.theosophical.org/files/resources/library/Bibliography/DyingLifeAfterDeath.pdf# Bibliography on Dying and Life after Death] from the [[Henry S. Olcott Memorial Library]]. | |||
== Notes == | |||
<references/> | |||
[[Category:Theosophical concepts]] | [[Category:Theosophical concepts]] | ||
[[es:Vida después de la muerte]] |
Latest revision as of 22:43, 14 December 2023
According to the Theosophical teachings after the death of the body, consciousness undergoes a series of transformations. The tendencies, emotions, thoughts, memories, and aspirations that were part of the personality are sorted out. Anything that belonged to the entirely personal and selfish aspect is discarded, while all that was of a generous or unselfish nature is preserved and assimilated by the soul. In the writings of H. P. Blavatsky and the Masters of Wisdom the most frequent description of the different stages after physical death include: a) kamaloka, b) gestation period, c) devachan, and d) reincarnation.
General description
In the Theosophical view, death is not the end of conscious experience but, on the contrary, it is the beginning of a wider consciousness. H. P. Blavatsky said:
We accept consciousness after death, and say the real consciousness and the real freedom of the Ego or the soul begins only after the physical death of man. It is then that it is no longer impeded by terrestrial matter that it is free, that it can perceive everything.[1]
What is known as "death" involves the departure of the vital principle and the consequent dissolution of the physical body along with its astral double of etheral matter. After this, comes a period of dissolution of the animal soul and the personal aspect of the human soul in Kāmaloka. Finally, the spiritual aspect of the human soul is assimilated by the spiritual soul in Devachan. In Mme. Blavatsky's words:
Soul being a generic term, there are in men three aspects of Soul - the terrestrial, or animal; the Human Soul; and the Spiritual Soul; these, strictly speaking, are one Soul in its three aspects. Now of the first aspect nothing remains after death; of the second (nous or Manas) only its divine essence if left unsoiled survives, while the third in addition to being immortal becomes consciously divine, by the assimilation of the higher Manas.[2]
The spiritual soul or Buddhi is of a universal nature and, by itself, it lacks the element of self-awareness. After death it can become conscious of its own divine nature by assimilating the spiritual elements of the mental consciousness, if the person ever exercised this aspect of his mind.
The different stages have been described by Master K.H. in one of his letters as follows:
The period between death and rebirth . . . may last from a few years to a kalpa. It is divided into three sub-periods (1) when the Ego delivered of its mortal coil enters into Kama-Loka (the abode of Elementaries); (2) when it enters into its "Gestation State"; (3) when it is reborn in the Rupa-Loka of Deva-Chan. Sub-period (1) may last from a few minutes to a number of years — the phrase "a few years" becoming puzzling and utterly worthless without a more complete explanation; Sub-period (2) is "very long"; as you say, longer sometimes than you may even imagine, yet proportionate to the Ego's spiritual stamina; Sub-period (3) lasts in proportion to the good KARMA, after which the monad is again reincarnated.[3]
Kama-loka
After the disposal of the three lower principles of consciousness that happen during physical death, the four principles remaining enter in Kāmaloka, which is an intermediate sphere between the physical and the spiritual. Before consciousness can pass on to devachan, a "purification" of the psychic elements is necessary. As H. P. Blavatsky wrote:
When the spiritual monad striving to enter the Devachanic state is being subjected to the process of purification, what happens is this: personal consciousness, which alone constitutes the personal Ego, has to rid itself of every earthly speck of grossly material taint before it becomes capable of living “in spirit” and as a spirit.[4]
Kama-loka may be compared to the dressing-room of an actor, in which he divests himself of the costume of the last part he played before rebecoming himself properly - the immortal Ego or the Pilgrim cycling in his Round of Incarnations. The Eternal Ego [is] stripped in Kama-loka of its lower terrestrial principles, with their passions and desires. . . . But the process of stripping off the lower, the fourth and part of the fifth, principles is an unconscious one in all normal human beings. It is only in very exceptional cases that there is a slight return to consciousness in Kama-loka: and this is the case of very materialistic unspiritual personalities, who, devoid of the conditions requisite, cannot enter the state of absolute Rest and Bliss.[5]
During this period there is a tension between the two lower principles, which possess a tendency towards materiality, and the two higher, which are of a spiritual nature. What happens can be metaphorically seen as a "struggle" between the animal and the spiritual aspects of the soul (Kāma and Buddhi respectively) to assimilate Manas. In one of his letters, Master K.H. explained the process as follows:
When man dies his second and third principles die with him; the lower triad disappears, and the fourth, fifth, sixth and seventh principles form the surviving Quaternary. . . . Thenceforth it is a "death" struggle between the Upper and Lower dualities. If the upper wins, the sixth, having attracted to itself the quintessence of Good from the fifth — its nobler affections, its saintly (though they be earthly) aspirations, and the most Spiritualised portions of its mind — follows its divine elder (the 7th) into the "Gestation" State; and the fifth and fourth remain in association as an empty shell . . . to roam in the earth's atmosphere, with half the personal memory gone, and the more brutal instincts fully alive for a certain period.[6]
After the death struggle the two higher principles, along with the spiritual essence of manas, enter into a period of gestation. Meanwhile, the fourth principle (Kāma), with whatever personal and selfish element it could retain from the manasic principle, forms a shell and stays in Kāmaloka to be eventually dissolved. However, it may happen that the upper duad does not succeed in assimilating any spiritual essence from the lower one. In such a case that particular personal life is completely useless to the Monad, and is "erased" from its records. As the Master continued saying:
If, on the other hand, it is the Upper Duality which is defeated, then it is the fifth principle that assimilates all that there may be left of personal recollection and perceptions of its personal individuality in the sixth. . . . The sixth and seventh [principles] — now a purely spiritual, individual MONAD, with nothing left in it of the late personality, having no regular “gestation” period to pass through (since there is no purified personal Ego to be reborn), after a more or less prolonged period of unconscious Rest in the boundless Space — will find itself reborn in another personality on the next planet. When arrives the period of “Full Individual Consciousness” — which precedes that of Absolute Consciousness in the Pari-Nirvana — this lost personal life becomes as a torn out page in the great Book of Lives, without even a disconnected word left to mark its absence. The purified monad will neither perceive nor remember it in the series of its past rebirths — which it would had it gone to the “World of Forms” (rupa-loka) — and its retrospective glance will not perceive even the slightest sign to indicate that it had been.[7]
In this case, the discarded personal elements do not become a regular "shell" to be dissolved in Kāmaloka. With the additional consciousness gained by retaining all the manasic elements used in that incarnation, it has enough cohesion to be reincarnated as a soul-less entity on earth. This state is called Avichi (see below).
Period of gestation
In most cases the upper duad finds some spiritual elements that allows it to be "born" in Devachan. But before this is possible the soul has to undergo a period of spiritual gestation. A. P. Sinnett wrote:
When the division of, or purification of the fifth principle has been accomplished in Kama loca by the contending attractions of the fourth and sixth principles, the real Ego passes into a period of unconscious gestation . . . a spiritual ante-natal state at the entrance to spiritual life . . . and this period, in different cases, may be of very different duration--from a few moments to immense periods of years.[8]
According to H. P. Blavatsky the gestation period "lasts from a few days to several years",[9] while Mahatma K.H. wrote that it can be very long: "longer sometimes than you may even imagine, yet proportionate to the Ego's spiritual stamina".[10]
It is usually said that the reviving of consciousness begins at the door of Devachan, once the struggle in Kama-Loka is over, but only after the period of gestation:[11]
That remembrance will return slowly and gradually toward the end of the gestation (to the entity or Ego), still more slowly but far more imperfectly and incompletely to the shell, and fully to the Ego at the moment of its entrance into the Devachan.[12]
However, there are some statements that indicate the possibility of consciousness before Devachan (see below).
Regarding the total time elapsed by a normal person in Kāmaloka (that is, during the death struggle and the period of gestation), Mme. Blavatsky wrote:
The normal period during which any part of the consciousness remains in Kâma-Loka, i.e., is connected with the Kâma-Rûpa, is one hundred and fifty years. The Kâma-Rûpa eventually breaks up, and leaving in Kâma-Loka the Tânhic Elementals, its remaining portions go into animals.[13]
Read more
Devachan
After the period of gestation, the new "devachanic ego" (that is, the pure elements of the personal ego that have been assimilated to the two higher principles) begins to awaken in Devachan:
The Eternal Ego being stripped in Kama-loka of its lower terrestrial principles, with their passions and desires, it enters into the state of Devachan. And therefore it is said that only the purely spiritual, the non-material emotions, affections and aspirations accompany the Ego into that state of Bliss.[14]
In one of his letters, Master K.H. wrote:
"Who goes to Deva Chan?" The personal Ego of course, but beatified, purified, holy. Every Ego - the combination of the sixth and seventh principles - which after the period of unconscious gestation is reborn into the Devachan, is of necessity as innocent and pure as a new-born babe. The fact of his being reborn [in Devachan] at all, shows the preponderance of good over evil in his old personality. And while the Karma (of evil) steps aside for the time being to follow him in his future earth-reincarnations, he brings along with him but the Karma of his good deeds, words, and thoughts, into this Devachan.[15]
In Devachan, the person enjoys the result of the good actions done in the life just finished, as well as receives a compensation for the unmerited suffering experienced:
Devachan is the idealized continuation of the terrestrial life just left behind, a period of retributive adjustment, and a reward for unmerited wrongs and sufferings undergone in that special Life.[16]
Reincarnation
When the period of Devachan is over, the higher ego begins the process of reincarnation. Before it is reborn, however, it sees the life about to be started in its general characteristics, as delineated by its Karma. Mme. Blavatsky wrote:
As the man at the moment of death has a retrospective insight into the life he has led, so, at the moment he is reborn on to earth, the Ego, awaking from the state of Devachan, has a prospective vision of the life which awaits him, and realizes all the causes that have led to it. He realizes them and sees futurity, because it is between Devachan and re-birth that the Ego regains his full manasic consciousness, and rebecomes for a short time the god he was, before, in compliance with Karmic law, he first descended into matter and incarnated in the first man of flesh.[17]
Avichi
Most people go to Devachan, with the exception of those very materialistic, selfish, or evil, in whom there is no spiritual manasic elements that can be assimilated by Buddhi. In this case, when no formation of a devachanic ego is possible, the higher principles fall into a state of unconsciousness[18] and the lower principles are eventually annihilated. Mme. Blavatsky explained:
The seventh and the sixth [principles], that is to say the immortal spirit and its vehicle, the immortal or spiritual soul, enter therein alone (an exceptional case). . . . The personal EGO (the material soul) . . . in the case of the irredeemably wicked and when the spiritual and impersonal soul has nothing to withdraw from its individuality (terrestrial personality) because the latter had nothing to offer but the purely material and sensual - that becomes annihilated.[19]
In one of his letters, Master K.H. explained the fate of the lower duad when it assimilates all the manasic elements as follows:
With all this additional stock, it will not remain in Kama-Loka — “the world of Desire” or our Earth’s atmosphere. In a very short time like a straw floating within the attraction of the vortices and pits of the Maelstrom, it is caught up and drawn into the great whirlpool of human Egos.[20]
Mme. Blavatsky elaborated:
Expelled forever from the consciousness of the Individuality (the reincarnating Ego), the physical atoms and psychic vibrations of the now separate personality are immediately reincarnated on the same earth, only in a lower and still more abject creature, a human being only in form, doomed to Karmic torments during the whole of its new life. Moreover, if it persists in its criminal or debauched course, it will suffer a long series of such immediate reincarnations.[21]
This state is called Avichi and could loosely be compared to a concept of hell for the lost personality (not for the Monad).
Is there consciousness before Devachan?
In the early Theosophical literature there are several statements suggesting consciousness only begins after the struggle in Kama-Loka at the door of Devachan:
Every just disembodied four-fold entity — whether it died a natural or violent death, from suicide or accident, mentally sane or insane, young or old, good, bad, or indifferent — loses at the instant of death all recollection, it is mentally — annihilated; it sleeps it’s akasic sleep in the Kama-loka. This state lasts from a few hours, (rarely less) days, weeks, months — sometimes to several years. All this according to the entity, to its mental status at the moment of death, to the character of its death, etc. That remembrance will return slowly and gradually toward the end of the gestation. . .[22]
However, there are some statements that open the possibility of consciousness before devachan. For example, Mme. Blavatsky wrote:
A “spirit,” or the spiritual Ego, cannot descend to the medium, but it can attract the spirit of the latter to itself, and it can do this only during the two intervals—before and after its “gestation period.” Interval the first is that period between the physical death and the merging of the spiritual Ego into that state which is known in the Arhat esoteric doctrine as “Bar-do.” We have translated this as the “gestation” period, and it lasts from a few days to several years, according to the evidence of the adepts. Interval the second lasts so long as the merits of the old Ego entitle the being to reap the fruit of its reward in its new regenerated Egoship. It occurs after the gestation period is over, and the new spiritual Ego is reborn—like the fabled Phœnix from its ashes—from the old one. The locality, which the former inhabits, is called by the northern Buddhist Occultists “Deva-chan”. . .[23]
As can be seen, she describes here the following sequence:
1- Physical death.
2- First interval.
3- Gestation.
4- Second interval (Devachan).
She mentions that the Spiritual Ego can attract to its own sphere the spirit of the medium in either of the intervals, which suggests there can be consciousness before the period of gestation. According to her, this can happen "when the intensity of the desire in the dying person to return for some purpose forced the higher consciousness to remain awake".[24]
According to Annie Besant
Dr. Annie Besant explained that "if a person has led a pure life and has steadfastly striven to rise and to identify himself with the higher rather than the lower part of his nature" the staying in Kāmaloka is short and normally unconscious. However, in those who during life have being attached to sensual pleasures the situation is different:
Human beings, who have quitted earth and in whom the kāmic elements were strong, may very readily be attracted by the kāmic elements in embodied men, and by their help become conscious again of the presence of the scenes they had left; and human beings still embodied may set up methods of communication with the disembodied, and may, as said, leave their own bodies for awhile, and become conscious in Kāmaloka by the use of faculties through which they have accustomed their consciousness to act.[25]
See also
Online resources
Articles and pamphlets
- Death and After-Death States in Theosophy World
- Death, Second in Theosophy World
- Earthbound Entities in Theosophy World
- Eight Sphere in Theosophy World.
- Life, and Life After Death by Annie Besant
- When a Man Dies, Shall He Live Again? by Annie Besant
- Dialogue On The Mysteries Of The After Life by H. P. Blavatsky
- Life and Death by H. P. Blavatsky
- The After-death Consciousness and Processes by Geoffrey Farthing
- After Death: You are Yourself by G. de Purucker
- Does the Personality Survive? by L. W. Rogers
- The Transpersonal Model of Death as Presented in Madame Blavatsky's Theosophy by Jean-Louis Siémons
- Death and Life Beyond by Theosophical Society in America
Books
- Death - and After? by Annie Besant
- Life beyond Death: evidence for survival by David Pratt
- After Death Consciousness and Processes by Geoffrey Farthing
- Book list on "Life After Death" compiled by Daniel H. Caldwell
Audio
- Life on the Other Side of Death by Clara Codd
- Through the Gateway of Death by Geoffrey Hodson
- Tibetan Contributions to Our Knowledge of Death and Dying (4 parts) by Glenn Mullin
Video
- I'm Dead! Now What? by Dick Brooks
- A Theosophical View of Life after Death by Pablo Sender
- What Happens When We Die by Blavatsky Trust
Additional resources
Notes
- ↑ Michael Gomes (transcriber), The Secret Doctrine Commentaries (The Hague: I.S.I.S. foundation, 2010), 44.
- ↑ Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, "The Key to Theosophy" (Pasadena, CA: Theosophical University Press, 1972), 121-122.
- ↑ Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence No. 68 (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 194.
- ↑ Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, Collected Writings vol. VI (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1989), 328.
- ↑ Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, Collected Writings vol. IX (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1974), 164.
- ↑ Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence No. 68 (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 192-193.
- ↑ Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence No. 68 (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 193.
- ↑ Alfred Percy Sinnett, Esoteric Buddhism (San Diego, CA: Wizards Bookshelf, 1987), 96-97.
- ↑ Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, Collected Writings vol. IV (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1991), 120-121.
- ↑ Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence No. 68 (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 194.
- ↑ Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence No. 104 (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 362.
- ↑ Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence No. 104 (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 362.
- ↑ Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, Collected Writings vol. XII (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1980), 708.
- ↑ Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, Collected Writings vol. IX (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1974), 164.
- ↑ Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence No. 68 (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 190.
- ↑ Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, The Key to Theosophy (London: Theosophical Publishing House, [1987]), 132.
- ↑ Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, The Key to Theosophy (London: Theosophical Publishing House, [1987]), 162-163.
- ↑ Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence No. 68 (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 193.
- ↑ Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, Collected Writings vol. V (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1997), 42.
- ↑ Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence No. 68 (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 193.
- ↑ Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, Collected Writings vol. XII (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1980), 632-633.
- ↑ Vicente Hao Chin, Jr., The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett in chronological sequence No. 85-B (Quezon City: Theosophical Publishing House, 1993), 263.
- ↑ Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, Collected Writings vol. IV (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1991), 120-121.
- ↑ Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, The Key to Theosophy (London:Theosophical Publishing House, [1987]), 151.
- ↑ Annie Besant, Death--And After? (Adyar, Madras:Theosophical Publishing House, 1977), 31.