Mahatma Letter No. 112: Difference between revisions

From Theosophy Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(21 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
[[Category:ML from Koot Hoomi]]
[[Category:ML needs background]]
[[Category:ML needs publication history]]
[[Category:ML needs commentary]]
{{Infobox MLbox
{{Infobox MLbox
| header1 = People involved |
| header1 = People involved |
Line 11: Line 7:
| writtendate      = unknown
| writtendate      = unknown
| receiveddate      = July 1883
| receiveddate      = July 1883
| otherdate        = none
| otherdate        = unknown
| header3 = Places
| header3 = Places
| sentfrom          = unknown
| sentfrom          = unknown
| receivedat        = London   
| receivedat        = London   
| vialocation      = none
| vialocation      = unknown{{pad|9em}}
}}
}}
'''This is Letter No. 81 in Barker numbering.''' See below for [[Mahatma Letter No. 112#Context and background|Context and background]].
This is '''Letter No. 112''' in ''' [[The Mahatma Letters to A. P. Sinnett (book)|''The Mahatma Letters to A. P. Sinnett'']], 4th chronological edition'''. It corresponds to '''Letter No. 81''' in '''Barker numbering.''' See below for [[Mahatma Letter No. 112#Context and background|Context and background]].
<br>
<br>
<br>
<br>
Line 34: Line 30:
<u>Private</u> but not <u>very</u> Confidential.
<u>Private</u> but not <u>very</u> Confidential.


I have, you observe, left for a separate private letter — in case you should like to read the other to your British "Brethren and Sistern" and to the last any reference to the [[Phoenix Venture|proposed new journal]], about whose prospects [[Lt. Col. W. Gordon|Col. Gordon]] has written you so encouragingly. I scarcely knew until I had begun to watch the development of this effort to erect a bulwark for Indian interests, how deeply my poor people had sunk. As one who watches the signs of fluttering life beside a dying bed, and counts the feeble breaths to learn if there may still be room for hope, so we Aryan exiles in our snowy retreat have been attentive to this issue. Debarred from using any [[Siddhi|abnormal powers]] that might interfere with the nation's [[Karma]], yet by all lawful and normal means trying to stimulate the zeal of those who care for our regard, we have seen weeks grow into months without the object having been achieved. Success is nearer than ever before, yet still in doubt. The letter of Gwindan Lal, which I shall ask [[Upasika]] to send you, shows that there is progress. In a few days a meeting of native capitalists is to be held at Madras, which [[Henry Steel Olcott|Mr. Olcott]] is to attend and from which there may be fruits. He will see the Gwikwar at Baroda and Holkar at Indore, and do his best — as he has already at Behar and in Bengal. There was never a time when the help of a man like yourself was more needed by
I have, you observe, left for a separate private letter — in case you should like to read the other to your British "Brethren and Sistern " and to the last any reference to the proposed new journal, about whose prospects [[William Gordon|Col. Gordon]] has written you so encouragingly. I scarcely knew until I had begun to watch the development of this effort to erect a bulwark for Indian interests, how deeply my poor people had sunk. As one who watches the signs of fluttering life beside a dying bed, and counts the feeble breaths to learn if there may still be room for hope, so we [[Mahatmas|Aryan exiles]] in our snowy retreat have been attentive to this issue. Debarred from using any abnormal powers that might interfere with the nation's [[Karma]], yet by all lawful and normal means trying to stimulate the zeal of those who care for our regard, we have seen weeks grow into months without the object having been achieved. Success is nearer than ever before, yet still in doubt. The letter of Gwindan Lal, which I shall ask [[Upasika]] to send you, shows that there is progress. In a few days a meeting of native capitalists is to be held at Madras, which [[Henry Steel Olcott|Mr. Olcott]] is to attend and from which there may be fruits. He will see the Gwikwar at Baroda and Holkar at Indore, and do his best — as he has already at Behar and in Bengal. There was never a time when the help of a man like yourself was more needed by


{{Col-break|width=3%}}
{{Col-break|width=3%}}
Line 43: Line 39:
{{Col-break|width=30%}}
{{Col-break|width=30%}}
'''NOTES:'''
'''NOTES:'''
*  
* The '''Gwikwar''' and '''Holkar''' were native rulers.


{{Col-end}}
{{Col-end}}
Line 51: Line 47:
{{Col-begin|width=98%}}
{{Col-begin|width=98%}}
{{Col-break|width=55%}}
{{Col-break|width=55%}}
India. We foresaw it, as you know and patriotically tried to make your way easy for a speedy return. But, — alas! that it must be confessed — the word Patriotism has now scarcely any electric power over the Indian heart. The "Cradle Land of Arts and Creeds" swarms with unhappy beings, precariously provided for, and vexed by demagogues who have everything to gain by chicane and impudence. We knew all this in the mass, but not one of us Aryans had sounded the depths of the Indian question as we have of late. If it be permissible to symbolize things subjective by phenomena objective, I should say that to the psychic sight India seems covered with a stifling grey fog — a moral meteor — the odic emanation from her vicious social state. Here and there twinkles a point of light which marks a nature still somewhat spiritual, a person who aspires and struggles after the higher knowledge. If the beacon of Aryan [[occultism]] shall ever be kindled again, these scattered sparks must be combined to make its flame. And this is the task of the [[Theosophical Society|T.S.]], this the pleasant part of its work in which we would so gladly assist, were we not impeded and thrown back by the <u>would-be [[chela]]s</u> themselves. I stepped outside our usual limits to aid your particular project from a conviction of its necessity and its potential usefulness: having begun I shall continue until the result is
India. We foresaw it, as you know and patriotically tried to make your way easy for a speedy return. But, — alas! that it must be confessed — the word Patriotism has now scarcely any electric power over the Indian heart. The "Cradle Land of Arts and Creeds" swarms with unhappy beings, precariously provided for, and vexed by demagogues who have everything to gain by chicane and impudence. We knew all this in the mass, but not one of us Aryans had sounded the depths of the Indian question as we have of late. If it be permissible to symbolize things subjective by phenomena objective, I should say that to the psychic sight India seems covered with a stifling grey fog — a moral meteor — the odic emanation from her vicious social state. Here and there twinkles a point of light which marks a nature still somewhat spiritual, a person who aspires and struggles after the higher knowledge. If the beacon of Aryan occultism shall ever be kindled again, these scattered sparks must be combined to make its flame. And this is the task of the T.S., this the pleasant part of its work in which we would so gladly assist, were we not impeded and thrown back by the <u>would-be chelas</u> themselves. I stepped outside our usual limits to aid your particular project from a conviction of its necessity and its potential usefulness: having begun I shall continue until the result is


{{Col-break|width=3%}}
{{Col-break|width=3%}}
Line 61: Line 57:
{{Col-break|width=30%}}
{{Col-break|width=30%}}
'''NOTES:'''
'''NOTES:'''
*  
* '''"Cradle Land of Arts and Creeds"''' refers to India.
* '''odic emanation''' refers to [[Odyle]], the Odic life force proposed by [[Carl Reichenbach]].


{{Col-end}}
{{Col-end}}
Line 69: Line 66:
{{Col-begin|width=98%}}
{{Col-begin|width=98%}}
{{Col-break|width=55%}}
{{Col-break|width=55%}}
is known. But in this uncongenial experience of meddling in a business affair, I have ventured within the very breath of the world's furnace. I have suffered so much from the enforced insight at short distance into the moral and spiritual condition of my people; and been so shocked by this nearer view of the selfish baseness of human nature (the concomitant, always, of the passage of humanity through our stage of the [[evolution]]ary circuit): I have seen so distinctly the certainty that it cannot be helped — that I shall henceforth abstain from any repetition of the unbearable experiment. Whether your paper should succeed or not — and if the latter, it will be due to <u>yourself</u> exclusively, to the unfortunate inspiration on the 17th, published in the Times — I shall have no more to do with the financial side of these worldly affairs; but confine myself to our prime duty of gaining knowledge and disseminating through all available channels such fragments as mankind in the mass may be ready to assimilate. I shall, of course, be interested in your journalistic career here — if I am able to overcome and soothe the bitter feelings you have just awakened in those who confided in you most, — by that unfortunate and <u><span style="border-bottom: 2px double #000;">untimely</span></u> confession, <u>honest as its object may have been</u> — and you may always depend upon my practical sympathy; but the genius of Mr. Dare must preside in your Counting Room as your own in the Editor's office. The great pain you have inflicted upon me, shows clearly that either I understand  
is known. But in this uncongenial experience of meddling in a business affair, I have ventured within the very breath of the world's furnace. I have suffered so much from the enforced insight at short distance into the moral and spiritual condition of my people; and been so shocked by this nearer view of the selfish baseness of human nature (the concomitant, always, of the passage of humanity through our stage of the evolutionary circuit): I have seen so distinctly the certainty that it cannot be helped — that I shall henceforth abstain from any repetition of the unbearable experiment. Whether your paper should succeed or not — and if the latter, it will be due to <u>yourself</u> exclusively, to the unfortunate inspiration on the 17th, published in the Times — I shall have no more to do with the financial side of these worldly affairs; but confine myself to our prime duty of gaining knowledge and disseminating through all available channels such fragments as mankind in the mass may be ready to assimilate. I shall, of course, be interested in your journalistic career here — if I am able to overcome and soothe the bitter feelings you have just awakened in those who confided in you most, — by that unfortunate and <u><span style="border-bottom: 2px double #000;">untimely</span></u> confession, <u>honest as its object may have been</u> — and you may always depend upon my practical sympathy; but the genius of Mr. Dare must preside in your Counting Room as your own in the Editor's office. The great pain you have inflicted upon me, shows clearly that either I understand  
{{Col-break|width=3%}}
{{Col-break|width=3%}}


{{Col-break|width=15%}}
{{Col-break|width=15%}}
[http://www.theosophy.wiki/mywiki/images/ML/112-3_7020.jpg http://www.theosophy.wiki/mywiki/images/ML/112-3_7020_thm.jpg]
[http://www.theosophy.wiki/mywiki/images/ML/112-3_7020.jpg http://www.theosophy.wiki/mywiki/images/ML/112-3_7020_thm.jpg]




{{Col-break|width=30%}}
{{Col-break|width=30%}}
'''NOTES:'''
'''NOTES:'''
* '''Published in the Times''' refers to a letter entitled "Public Feeling in India" that Mr. Sinnett wrote on May 17th and sent to a newspaper, probably the ''Bombay Times'', which was published on Saturday, [[May 19]]th.
* '''Published in the Times''' refers to a letter entitled [[Public Feeling in India (letter)|"Public Feeling in India"]] that Mr. Sinnett sent to the ''London Times''.


{{Col-end}}
{{Col-end}}
Line 87: Line 83:
{{Col-begin|width=98%}}
{{Col-begin|width=98%}}
{{Col-break|width=55%}}
{{Col-break|width=55%}}
nothing in the fitness of political duties and therefore, could hardly hope to be a wise business & <u>political</u> "control" or that the man whom I regard as a true friend, however honest and willing, will never rise above English prejudices and the sinful antipathy towards <u>our race</u> and colour. [[Helena Petrovna Blavatsky|"Madame"]] will tell you more.
nothing in the fitness of political duties and therefore, could hardly hope to be a wise business & <u>political</u> "control" or that the man whom I regard as a true friend, however honest and willing, will never rise above English prejudices and the sinful antipathy towards <u>our race</u> and colour. "Madame" will tell you more.


Though you do not "ask me to deal with it afresh" yet I will say two words more about [[C. C. Massey|Mr. Massey]]'s difficulty as regards the letter from our [[Hillarion|Brother H----]] then in Scotland, sent him circuituously through "[[Mary Hollis Billing#Ski|Ski]]". Be just and charitable to — a European at least. If Mr. Massey had "declared to the English [[Spiritualism|spiritualists]] that he was in communication <u>with</u> <u>the</u> <u><span style="border-bottom: 2px double #000;">Brothers</span></u> by [[Occultism|Occult]] means" he would have spoken the simple truth. For not only once but twice had he such occult relationship — once with his Father's glove, sent him by [[Morya|M.]] through "Ski" and again with the note in question, for the delivery of which the same practical agency was employed, though without an equal expenditure of power. His, you see, is one more example of the ease with which even a superior intellect may deceive itself in occult matters, by the [[Māyā|maya]] of its own engendering. And, as regards the other case, may it not be noted — I am no barrister and therefore speak under reserve — as a mitigating circumstance for the accused that Mr. Massey is not even to this day sure that [[Harry J. Billing|Dr. Billing]] did not intercept the Simpson letter to his wife, keep it to use against her at a fortunate time and actually
Though you do not "ask me to deal with it afresh" yet I will say two words more about [[C. C. Massey|Mr. Massey's]] difficulty as regards the letter from our Brother H---- then in Scotland, sent him circuituously through [[Mary_Hollis_Billing#Ski|"Ski"]]. Be just and charitable to — a European at least. If Mr. Massey had "declared to the English [[spiritualism|spiritualists]] that he was in communication <u>with</u> <u>the</u> <u><span style="border-bottom: 2px double #000;">Brothers</span></u> by Occult means" he would have spoken the simple truth. For not only once but twice had he such occult relationship — once with his Father's glove, sent him by [[Morya|M.]] through "Ski" and again with the note in question, for the delivery of which the same practical agency was employed, though without an equal expenditure of power. His, you see, is one more example of the ease with which even a superior intellect may deceive itself in occult matters, by the [[maya]] of its own engendering. And, as regards the other case, may it not be noted — I am no barrister and therefore speak under reserve — as a mitigating circumstance for the accused that Mr. Massey is not even to this day sure that Dr. Billing did not intercept the Simpson letter to his wife, keep it to use against her at a fortunate time and actually


{{Col-break|width=3%}}
{{Col-break|width=3%}}
Line 99: Line 95:
{{Col-break|width=30%}}
{{Col-break|width=30%}}
'''NOTES:'''
'''NOTES:'''
* '''Then in Scotland'''. In January 1879 Master Hillarion was involved in the transmission of a letter to C. C. Massey through one of [[Mary Hollis Billing]]'s [[Mediumship#Spirit_guides|spirit guides]].
* '''"Madame" will tell you more''' See [https://www.theosociety.org/pasadena/hpb-aps/bl-25.htm# Blavatsky Letter No. 25]
*'''Mrs. R. C. Simpson'' was a celebrated slate-writer and test medium from Boston.
* '''Ski''' was an Indian spirit guide of [[Mary Hollis Billing|Mrs. Hollis Billing]].
 
* '''Brother H----''' may refer to Master [[Hilarion]].<ref>Joy Mills, ''Reflections on an Ageless Wisdom'' (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 2010), 352.</ref>
* '''Simpson''' refers to Mrs. R. C. Simpson, who was a celebrated medium from Boston.
{{Col-end}}
{{Col-end}}


Line 108: Line 105:
{{Col-begin|width=98%}}
{{Col-begin|width=98%}}
{{Col-break|width=55%}}
{{Col-break|width=55%}}
so use it in this instance? Or, even allowing the letter to have been delivered to the addressee, know what was the answer — if any written? Has the idea struck your observant friend that, at that very time there was a womanly — worse than that — [[Mediumship|medium]]'s spite far worse than the <u>odium theologicum</u> between the Simpson and [[Mary Hollis Billing|Hollis-Billing]], concerning their respective claims to the favours shown by [[Mary Hollis Billing#Ski|Ski]]? That Mrs. Billing called the Ski of her "friend" Simpson "a <u>bogus</u> spook;" that [[Harry J. Billing|Dr. Billing]] complained bitterly to [[Henry Steel Olcott|Olcott]] and [[Helena Petrovna Blavatsky|H.P.B.]] of the fraud perpetrated by the Simpson who tried to palm off a false Ski as the genuine one — the oldest as the most faithful "control" of his wife. The row got even into the papers. Strange, that at the time when she was publicly reproached by Mrs. B. with pretending to be controlled by <u>her</u> Ski Mrs. S. should have asked her for such a delicate and dangerous service! I say again — I speak under reserve — I have never looked into the accusation seriously, and know of it by having caught a glimpse of the situation in Olcott's head when reading [[C. C. Massey|Mr. C. C. M.]]'s letter. But the hint may, perchance, be of some service. But this I do know, and say; the long and short of the matter is, that your friend has hastily suspected and <u>unjustly</u> condemned the innocent and done himself harm spiritually. He really has no right to accuse even H.P.B. of <u>deliberate deceit</u>. I protest most emphatically against the woman being dealt with so uncharitably. She had no intention to deceive — unless withholding a fact be a direct deceit and <u>lie</u>, on  
so use it in this instance? Or, even allowing the letter to have been delivered to the addressee, know what was the answer — if any written? Has the idea struck your observant friend that, at that very time there was a womanly — worse than that — medium's spite far worse than the <u>odium theologicum</u> between the Simpson and Hollis-Billing, concerning their respective claims to the favours shown by Ski? That Mrs. Billing called the Ski of her "friend" Simpson "a <u>bogus</u> spook;" that Dr. Billing complained bitterly to Olcott and H.P.B. of the fraud perpetrated by the Simpson who tried to palm off a false Ski as the genuine one — the oldest as the most faithful "control" of his wife. The row got even into the papers. Strange, that at the time when she was publicly reproached by Mrs. B. with pretending to be controlled by <u>her</u> Ski Mrs. S. should have asked her for such a delicate and dangerous service! I say again — I speak under reserve — I have never looked into the accusation seriously, and know of it by having caught a glimpse of the situation in Olcott's head when reading Mr. C. C. M.'s letter. But the hint may, perchance, be of some service. But this I do know, and say; the long and short of the matter is, that your friend has hastily suspected and <u>unjustly</u> condemned the innocent and done himself harm spiritually. He really has no right to accuse even H.P.B. of <u>deliberate deceit</u>. I protest most emphatically against the woman being dealt with so uncharitably. She had no intention to deceive — unless withholding a fact be a direct deceit and <u>lie</u>, on  


{{Col-break|width=3%}}
{{Col-break|width=3%}}
Line 119: Line 116:
'''NOTES:'''
'''NOTES:'''
* '''odium theologicum''' or "theological hatred" in Latin refers to intense anger and hatred generated by disputes over theology; rancorous disputes.
* '''odium theologicum''' or "theological hatred" in Latin refers to intense anger and hatred generated by disputes over theology; rancorous disputes.
*'''Simpson'''. See [[Mahatma_Letter_No._112#Page 4|previous note]].
* '''C. C. M.''' refers to [[C. C. Massey]].


{{Col-end}}
{{Col-end}}
Line 127: Line 124:
{{Col-begin|width=98%}}
{{Col-begin|width=98%}}
{{Col-break|width=55%}}
{{Col-break|width=55%}}
the theory <u>suppressio veri, suggestis falsi</u> — a legal maxim which she knows nothing about. But then on this theory we all ([[Masters of Wisdom|Brothers]] and [[Chela]]s) ought to be regarded <u>as liars</u>. She was ordered to see that the letter should be delivered; she had no other means of doing so at that time but through "<u>[[Mary Hollis Billing#Ski|Ski]]</u>." She had no power of sending it <u>direct</u>, as was the glove; [[Morya|M.]] <u>would not</u> help her, for certain reasons of his and very weighty too — as I have found out later —; she knew [[C. C. Massey|Mr. C. C. M.]] distrusted <u>Ski</u>, and was foolish enough to believe that Mr. Massey separated the [[Mediumship|medium]] from the "[[Mediumship#Spirit_guides|spirit]]" as proved by her letter; she was anxious out of pure and unselfish devotion for him that he should see that he was noticed at last by a real Brother. Hence — she tried to conceal the fact that Ski had a hand in it. Moreover, an hour after having sent her letter to [[Mary Hollis Billing|Mrs. B.]] to be delivered by Ski, a letter <u>read at the time</u>, not found <u>accidentally</u> as alleged — she forgot all about it as she forgets everything. No idea, no thought of the slightest deceit on her part had ever crossed her mind. Had Mr. Massey asked her to tell him honestly the truth, after the letter had been shown to him she would have probably, either sent him to a very hot place, and said nothing, or honestly confessed the truth. She simply thought it best that the intended good effect of the Brother's message should not be cancelled by arousing in Mr. C. C. M.'s mind a hostile disposition the fruit of such unwarranted suspicion. We, my dear sirs, always judge men by their motives and the moral effects of their actions: for the world's false standards and prejudice we have no respect.
the theory <u>suppressio veri, suggestis falsi</u> — a legal maxim which she knows nothing about. But then on this theory we all (Brothers and Chelas) ought to be regarded <u>as liars</u>. She was ordered to see that the letter should be delivered; she had no other means of doing so at that time but through "<u>Ski</u>." She had no power of sending it <u>direct</u>, as was the glove; M. <u>would not</u> help her, for certain reasons of his and very weighty too — as I have found out later —; she knew Mr. C. C. M. distrusted <u>Ski</u>, and was foolish enough to believe that Mr. Massey separated the medium from the "spirit" as proved by her letter; she was anxious out of pure and unselfish devotion for him that he should see that he was noticed at last by a real Brother. Hence — she tried to conceal the fact that Ski had a hand in it. Moreover, an hour after having sent her letter to Mrs. B. to be delivered by Ski, a letter <u>read at the time</u>, not found <u>accidentally</u> as alleged — she forgot all about it as she forgets everything. No idea, no thought of the slightest deceit on her part had ever crossed her mind. Had Mr. Massey asked her to tell him honestly the truth, after the letter had been shown to him she would have probably, either sent him to a very hot place, and said nothing, or honestly confessed the truth. She simply thought it best that the intended good effect of the Brother's message should not be cancelled by arousing in Mr. C. C. M.'s mind a hostile disposition the fruit of such unwarranted suspicion. We, my dear sirs, always judge men by their motives and the moral effects of their actions: for the world's false standards and prejudice we have no respect.


[[Koot Hoomi|K. H.]]
K. H.


{{Col-break|width=3%}}
{{Col-break|width=3%}}
Line 140: Line 137:
{{Col-break|width=30%}}
{{Col-break|width=30%}}
'''NOTES:'''
'''NOTES:'''
* '''Suppressio veri, suggestio falsi''' in Latin translates as "the suppression of the truth is a suggestion of a falsehood".
* '''suppressio veri, suggestio falsi''' in Latin is a suppression of truth is suggesting a falsehood.


{{Col-end}}
{{Col-end}}


== Context and background ==
== Context and background ==
 
On May 17th, Mr. Sinnett wrote and sent to the ''London Times'' a letter entitled [[Public Feeling in India (letter)|"Public Feeling in India"]], which was published on Saturday, May 19th. This letter, which criticizes both aspects of the British government and the natives' actions, gave a pretext for reluctant Indian supporters to withdraw their funding of the [[Phoenix Venture|Phoenix newspaper]]. For more information about this see [https://www.theosociety.org/pasadena/hpb-aps/bl-23.htm# Blavatsky Letters No. 23] and [https://www.theosociety.org/pasadena/hpb-aps/bl-25.htm 25].


== Physical description of letter ==
== Physical description of letter ==
Line 162: Line 159:
== Notes ==
== Notes ==
<references/>
<references/>
<br>


== Additional resources ==
[[Category:ML from Koot Hoomi]]
[[Category:ML needs background]]
[[Category:ML to A. P. Sinnett]]
[[Category:ML with images]]
[[Category:ML needs commentary]]

Latest revision as of 02:05, 30 March 2022

Quick Facts
People involved
Written by: Koot Hoomi
Received by: A. P. Sinnett
Sent via: unknown
Dates
Written on: unknown
Received on: July 1883
Other dates: unknown
Places
Sent from: unknown
Received at: London
Via: unknown 

This is Letter No. 112 in The Mahatma Letters to A. P. Sinnett, 4th chronological edition. It corresponds to Letter No. 81 in Barker numbering. See below for Context and background.

< Prev letter chrono  Next letter chrono >  
< Prev letter Barker  Next letter Barker >

Page 1 transcription, image, and notes

Received London about July, 1883. Private but not very Confidential.

I have, you observe, left for a separate private letter — in case you should like to read the other to your British "Brethren and Sistern —" and to the last any reference to the proposed new journal, about whose prospects Col. Gordon has written you so encouragingly. I scarcely knew until I had begun to watch the development of this effort to erect a bulwark for Indian interests, how deeply my poor people had sunk. As one who watches the signs of fluttering life beside a dying bed, and counts the feeble breaths to learn if there may still be room for hope, so we Aryan exiles in our snowy retreat have been attentive to this issue. Debarred from using any abnormal powers that might interfere with the nation's Karma, yet by all lawful and normal means trying to stimulate the zeal of those who care for our regard, we have seen weeks grow into months without the object having been achieved. Success is nearer than ever before, yet still in doubt. The letter of Gwindan Lal, which I shall ask Upasika to send you, shows that there is progress. In a few days a meeting of native capitalists is to be held at Madras, which Mr. Olcott is to attend and from which there may be fruits. He will see the Gwikwar at Baroda and Holkar at Indore, and do his best — as he has already at Behar and in Bengal. There was never a time when the help of a man like yourself was more needed by

112-1_7018_thm.jpg

NOTES:

  • The Gwikwar and Holkar were native rulers.

Page 2

India. We foresaw it, as you know and patriotically tried to make your way easy for a speedy return. But, — alas! that it must be confessed — the word Patriotism has now scarcely any electric power over the Indian heart. The "Cradle Land of Arts and Creeds" swarms with unhappy beings, precariously provided for, and vexed by demagogues who have everything to gain by chicane and impudence. We knew all this in the mass, but not one of us Aryans had sounded the depths of the Indian question as we have of late. If it be permissible to symbolize things subjective by phenomena objective, I should say that to the psychic sight India seems covered with a stifling grey fog — a moral meteor — the odic emanation from her vicious social state. Here and there twinkles a point of light which marks a nature still somewhat spiritual, a person who aspires and struggles after the higher knowledge. If the beacon of Aryan occultism shall ever be kindled again, these scattered sparks must be combined to make its flame. And this is the task of the T.S., this the pleasant part of its work in which we would so gladly assist, were we not impeded and thrown back by the would-be chelas themselves. I stepped outside our usual limits to aid your particular project from a conviction of its necessity and its potential usefulness: having begun I shall continue until the result is

112-2_7019_thm.jpg


NOTES:

  • "Cradle Land of Arts and Creeds" refers to India.
  • odic emanation refers to Odyle, the Odic life force proposed by Carl Reichenbach.

Page 3

is known. But in this uncongenial experience of meddling in a business affair, I have ventured within the very breath of the world's furnace. I have suffered so much from the enforced insight at short distance into the moral and spiritual condition of my people; and been so shocked by this nearer view of the selfish baseness of human nature (the concomitant, always, of the passage of humanity through our stage of the evolutionary circuit): I have seen so distinctly the certainty that it cannot be helped — that I shall henceforth abstain from any repetition of the unbearable experiment. Whether your paper should succeed or not — and if the latter, it will be due to yourself exclusively, to the unfortunate inspiration on the 17th, published in the Times — I shall have no more to do with the financial side of these worldly affairs; but confine myself to our prime duty of gaining knowledge and disseminating through all available channels such fragments as mankind in the mass may be ready to assimilate. I shall, of course, be interested in your journalistic career here — if I am able to overcome and soothe the bitter feelings you have just awakened in those who confided in you most, — by that unfortunate and untimely confession, honest as its object may have been — and you may always depend upon my practical sympathy; but the genius of Mr. Dare must preside in your Counting Room as your own in the Editor's office. The great pain you have inflicted upon me, shows clearly that either I understand

112-3_7020_thm.jpg


NOTES:

Page 4

nothing in the fitness of political duties and therefore, could hardly hope to be a wise business & political "control" or that the man whom I regard as a true friend, however honest and willing, will never rise above English prejudices and the sinful antipathy towards our race and colour. "Madame" will tell you more.

Though you do not "ask me to deal with it afresh" yet I will say two words more about Mr. Massey's difficulty as regards the letter from our Brother H---- then in Scotland, sent him circuituously through "Ski". Be just and charitable to — a European at least. If Mr. Massey had "declared to the English spiritualists that he was in communication with the Brothers by Occult means" he would have spoken the simple truth. For not only once but twice had he such occult relationship — once with his Father's glove, sent him by M. through "Ski" and again with the note in question, for the delivery of which the same practical agency was employed, though without an equal expenditure of power. His, you see, is one more example of the ease with which even a superior intellect may deceive itself in occult matters, by the maya of its own engendering. And, as regards the other case, may it not be noted — I am no barrister and therefore speak under reserve — as a mitigating circumstance for the accused that Mr. Massey is not even to this day sure that Dr. Billing did not intercept the Simpson letter to his wife, keep it to use against her at a fortunate time and actually

112-4_7021_thm.jpg


NOTES:

Page 5

so use it in this instance? Or, even allowing the letter to have been delivered to the addressee, know what was the answer — if any written? Has the idea struck your observant friend that, at that very time there was a womanly — worse than that — medium's spite far worse than the odium theologicum between the Simpson and Hollis-Billing, concerning their respective claims to the favours shown by Ski? That Mrs. Billing called the Ski of her "friend" Simpson "a bogus spook;" that Dr. Billing complained bitterly to Olcott and H.P.B. of the fraud perpetrated by the Simpson who tried to palm off a false Ski as the genuine one — the oldest as the most faithful "control" of his wife. The row got even into the papers. Strange, that at the time when she was publicly reproached by Mrs. B. with pretending to be controlled by her Ski Mrs. S. should have asked her for such a delicate and dangerous service! I say again — I speak under reserve — I have never looked into the accusation seriously, and know of it by having caught a glimpse of the situation in Olcott's head when reading Mr. C. C. M.'s letter. But the hint may, perchance, be of some service. But this I do know, and say; the long and short of the matter is, that your friend has hastily suspected and unjustly condemned the innocent and done himself harm spiritually. He really has no right to accuse even H.P.B. of deliberate deceit. I protest most emphatically against the woman being dealt with so uncharitably. She had no intention to deceive — unless withholding a fact be a direct deceit and lie, on

112-5_7022_thm.jpg


NOTES:

  • odium theologicum or "theological hatred" in Latin refers to intense anger and hatred generated by disputes over theology; rancorous disputes.
  • C. C. M. refers to C. C. Massey.

Page 6

the theory suppressio veri, suggestis falsi — a legal maxim which she knows nothing about. But then on this theory we all (Brothers and Chelas) ought to be regarded as liars. She was ordered to see that the letter should be delivered; she had no other means of doing so at that time but through "Ski." She had no power of sending it direct, as was the glove; M. would not help her, for certain reasons of his and very weighty too — as I have found out later —; she knew Mr. C. C. M. distrusted Ski, and was foolish enough to believe that Mr. Massey separated the medium from the "spirit" as proved by her letter; she was anxious out of pure and unselfish devotion for him that he should see that he was noticed at last by a real Brother. Hence — she tried to conceal the fact that Ski had a hand in it. Moreover, an hour after having sent her letter to Mrs. B. to be delivered by Ski, a letter read at the time, not found accidentally as alleged — she forgot all about it as she forgets everything. No idea, no thought of the slightest deceit on her part had ever crossed her mind. Had Mr. Massey asked her to tell him honestly the truth, after the letter had been shown to him she would have probably, either sent him to a very hot place, and said nothing, or honestly confessed the truth. She simply thought it best that the intended good effect of the Brother's message should not be cancelled by arousing in Mr. C. C. M.'s mind a hostile disposition the fruit of such unwarranted suspicion. We, my dear sirs, always judge men by their motives and the moral effects of their actions: for the world's false standards and prejudice we have no respect.

K. H.

112-6_7023_thm.jpg


NOTES:

  • suppressio veri, suggestio falsi in Latin is a suppression of truth is suggesting a falsehood.

Context and background

On May 17th, Mr. Sinnett wrote and sent to the London Times a letter entitled "Public Feeling in India", which was published on Saturday, May 19th. This letter, which criticizes both aspects of the British government and the natives' actions, gave a pretext for reluctant Indian supporters to withdraw their funding of the Phoenix newspaper. For more information about this see Blavatsky Letters No. 23 and 25.

Physical description of letter

The original is in the British Library, Folio 3. George Linton and Virginia Hanson described the letter this way:

In bright blue ink, on both sides of three full-sized sheets of white paper, in fine KH script.[2]

Publication history

Commentary about this letter

Notes

  1. Joy Mills, Reflections on an Ageless Wisdom (Wheaton, IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 2010), 352.
  2. George E. Linton and Virginia Hanson, eds., Readers Guide to The Mahatma Letters to A. P. Sinnett (Adyar, Chennai, India: Theosophical Publishing House, 1972), 181.