Mahatma Letter of Finch to Sinnett - 1883-12-21

Quick Facts
People involved
Written by:	G. B. Finch, A. P. Sinnett, Koot Hoomi
Received by:	A. P. Sinnett, Koot Hoomi, H. P. Blavatsky
Sent via:	unknown
Dates
Written on:	12 December 1883
Received on:	unknown
Other dates:	unknown
Places
Sent from:	unknown
Received at:	unknown
Via:	unknown

This letter has not been published previously. G. B. Finch wrote to A. P. Sinnett, who forwarded it to Mahatma Koot Hoomi, via H. P. Blavatsky, "for considerations." KH instructed HPB to keep the letter and to show Mohini. Finch provided a nuanced view of the London Lodge before its split, and of Anna Bonus Kingsford and Edward Maitland.

Notes to H. P. Blavatsky from K.H.

Note written in blue ink in KH handwriting at the top of the first page:

For Upasikaa to preserve KH

Underscores written in blue ink in KH handwriting at the bottom of the fourth page:

I wrote Col. O. from Capri [underlined in blue] that I would come if you approved I got no notice until yesterday [underlined in blue] of your assent.

NOTES:

Page 1 of Ward letter transcription, image, and notes

36 Piccadilly
14 Dec 1883

My dear and revered friend,

I have not written lately because I feared what your patience who know so fully the human causes that have arisen to sow dissension in our camp at which I fervently believe you now and then take a look of scrutiny realising at a glance more than pen can describe.

Alas! if Astronomers in the observatory are compelled to take into account what they call the “human equation” how much more needful is it to estimate that irregularity where undisciplined ambitions and mixed motives combined as perturbing forces.

I never have ceased to venerate the lofty soar of our Seeress,- but from the first I have despaired of her ever becoming a teacher to a large congregation. This arises

NOTES:

• Seeress refers to Anna Bonus Kingsford.

Page 2

quite as much from the elevation of the plane her spirit has attained as from any defects inherent in her sex. I can conceive the inability of Newton or Huyghens [Christiaan Huygens – 1600s scientist] to teach a schoolboy the binomial theorem, and my friend the late Professor Pervie of Harvard who dwelt among the Himalayan Mountaintops of the higher Analysis was noted for his incompetency to impart a spark of his love to any save the 3 or 4 exceptional students in a large class.

I think we shall tide over the difficulty which Massey suggests might be compromised by the election of Mr. Hood or some other advanced member as President and thus retain both Mrs K and the OL’s [Old Lady’s] “Boss” without the Scandal of a spasmodic disruption. He would propose to follow this up by a division of the T.S., like the British Association into branches who may pursue ‘Esoteric Buddhism’ under Sinnett,- or ‘Esoteric Christianity’ under the Seeress.

But the latter is in precarious

NOTES:

Page 3

NOTES:

Page 4

Written across middle of page in Sinnett’s script:

Mahatma K.H.

Written in blue ink in KH handwriting:

File with the other letters – let Mohini see. KH

NOTES:

Context and background

This letter was written about six months earlier than the important correspondence between members of the London Lodge (including Finch) and the Mahatmas, which was published as Letter No. 5 in Letters from the Masters of the Wisdom, First Series. On April 7, 1884, Mr. Finch was elected as President of the lodge, with Mr. Sinnett as Vice-President and Secretary, and Miss Francesca Arundale as Treasurer. Col. Olcott, international President of the Theosophical Society, who was visiting London with his personal secretary Mohini, granted a charter for the Kingsford-Maitland contingent to form a separate Branch, the Hermetic Lodge.

Physical description of letter

One sheet of paper was folded and written on both sides. Notation by K.H. is in blue ink. This letter is in a private collection.

Publication history

This letter has never been published before.

Commentary about this letter

The chief significance of this letter is that K.H. recognized it as an important communication about interactions within the London Lodge, and therefore instructed Madame Blavatsky to preserve it.